Apple has scored a legal victory in United Kingdom, as a a government tribunal has turned down the UK Home Office’s request to keep private the iPhone maker’s challenge to the government’s demand for “backdoor” access to encrypted Apple customer data secret, reports the Financial Times. Apple’s challenge to the demand can now be heard mostly in public.
Apple refused to bow to the UK’s request, and instead disabled Advanced Data Protection in the country.
Apple has long battled governments both at home and abroad, as the governments have pushed for access to iCloud users’ data. All iCloud data is end-to-end encrypted, with no one other than users having the ability to decrypt the data. Even Apple cannot access users’ encrypted data.
In September, Apple demanded the the UK’s Home Office admit publicly that it has secretly ordered Apple to provide “backdoor” access to Apple customers’ iCloud data. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal today ruled that the British government had failed to show how Apple’s demand would damage national security. The government will now be required to publicly acknowledge serving Apple with a technical capability notice (TCN), which is an order from the government forcing companies to make their customers’ data accessible to UK security services, even when the data is encrypted.
The UK government usually doesn’t confirm or deny such orders, although the tribunal found that the government had departed from that policy by disclosing such requests to both the media and US officials.
The tribunal’s ruling means that much of the legal action brought by Apple, in addition to a second challenge by Privacy International and Liberty, will be able to proceed in open court.
Apple says allowing such access would violate the company’s user privacy policies. The British order would require Apple to provide wide-ranging access to all encrypted materials, not merely the data from a specific account. Plus the order covers all users around the globe, not just in the UK.
The tribunal will now hear much of the arguments over the government’s demands in public. Privacy International says the substantive hearing for its separate legal challenge is scheduled for December 2026.