• Home
  • Apple
  • News
  • Samsung Demands Retrial in Apple Patent Case, Claims Verdict Was Unfair

Samsung Demands Retrial in Apple Patent Case, Claims Verdict Was Unfair

Samsung Demands Retrial in Apple Patent Case, Claims Verdict Was Unfair

Following Samsung’s recent $1 billion court loss to Apple, in which the jury found the company in violation of a number of Apple’s patents, Samsung now claims that the trial was unfair, and that the jury used outside information not approved by the court to make their decision.

CNET reports:

Samsung is alleging juror misconduct in new court filings asking a federal judge to throw out Apple’s billion-dollar jury verdict and allow a new trial.

In a flurry of court documents, Samsung’s attorneys list a series of cases, including ones that federal courts in California must follow, in which juror misconduct prompted a new trial. Their apparent argument: interviews that jurors in the landmark case gave to news organizations provide evidence of misconduct serious enough to have influenced the verdict.

Samsung claims that jury foreman Velvin Hogan used his patent expertise to “guide” the rest of the jury to the conclusion that they reached, shaping their views on what should and should and should not be considered prior art. The foreman had also been warned beforehand that decisions should be based according to the law alone, and not based on your understanding of the law based on your own cases.”

The report cites a claim from Manuel Ilagan, one of the jurors in the case:

“Some were not sure of how prior art could either render a patent acceptable or whether it could invalidate it,” Hogan said during an interview with Bloomberg. “What we did is we started talking about one… (I) laid it out for them.”

It’s very uncommon for a jury verdict to be overturned or officially investigated after the fact; nevertheless, Samsung cites a number of cases which were in fact overturned for jury misconduct.

While I can’t comment on the validity of Samsung’s claims (though I do have certain reservations on the subject), if I were Samsung, I’d certainly want a do-over too!


  1. iamchandlerbing says:

    i don’t know what justice means really.

  2. MRonin says:

    It is clear that this matter wont be over anytime soon with Apple appearing to do a money grab and samsung still acting like petulant children. I’m going to just ignore any coverage of the case from now on. It’s become nothing more than a tired and tiresome circus.

  3. 950465 307579I ran into this page accidentally, surprisingly, this really is a terrific internet site. The web site owner has done a fantastic job writing/collecting articles to post, the information here is actually insightful. You just secured yourself a guarenteed reader. 288058

  4. 644588 438873How much of an exciting piece of writing, continue creating companion 706881

  5. Marijuana says:

    376360 546738I like this website its a master peace ! Glad I detected this on google . 52285

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *